Hmmm.... don't know what to say and have not said anything up to now.... but I also can't leave things like this.
Why all the underlying resentment and unhappiness? *sigh*
Aren't we all just detailers that love detailing?
There are many products with many different uses. Are they all the same? Most definitely not!
Everyone has an opinion and we can't control everything that is written about any product but that doesn't mean either that one is right and the other wrong, just two differing opinions.
It is indeed disappointing to read some of the post which have implied that untrue facts (which is an oxymoron in itself) have been spread... but let's look at the facts.
KC just shared how easily it is to clean a dirty wheel arch with OPC. Indeed OPC is a great product and does make it very easy to clean stubborn stains
SAFELY.
Does this mean that there are no other products that can do the same? Of course not!
Anyone wanting to start their own thread on how you can clean wheel arches with washing detergent/floor cleaners/acid/thinner/some other APC/degreaser/etc are most welcome to do so as well. We were just sharing what can be done with OPC.
Can you achieve the same with the many other brands on the market? Of course you can!
Perhaps some of this controversy was started by ShowTime's statement on how OPC is safe for the paint while other products may not be. Controversial statement?
Indeed...
ShowTime is a hardcore detailing enthusiast who meticulously maintains his ride in pristine condition and that was just his opinion.
Was what he posted an untrue fact?
Best to just go back to basics and examine the facts of the matter to get to the true facts... :-)
Technically, as Fish pointed out, a degreaser is just a stronger cleaner but then again, there are many different types available on the market.
Optimum is based in the USA and there are legal requirements on what can be printed on labels and there are requirements to maintain MSDS sheets etc.
IS OPC SAFE FOR PAINT COMPARED WITH DEGREASERS FROM OTHER MANUFACTURERS?
Optimum clearly states on their label that
OPC is environmentally friendly, safe on all vehicle surfaces and SAFE FOR THE USER.
What about the other products from other manufacturers?
Let's compare the
FACTS!
As an example.... and for illustration purposes only as the label and MSDS for this product is also readily available and it is also made in the USA.
Meguiar's Super Degreaser.
A great product for what it does, which is to degrease engine bays etc. I was also a Meguiar's user before switching over to Optimum and they make great products.
However, while the Meg's SD is great for degreasing engine bays, it is not recommended for use on paint. Which is what started all of this controversy in the first place isn't it?
Can you use other products for paint or leather? OF COURSE! But are you sure you want to?
Let's check out the
FACTS on this matter.
The MSDS sheets for both of these products are available here:
OPC:
http://www.optimumcarcare.com.au/msds/MSDS%20Power%20Clean%20PC2008%202009%281%29.pdf
Meg's Super Degreaser:
http://www.meguiars.com.au/msds_files/D10805.pdf
Do download them, print them out and study them carefully. It is a legal disclosure document that all manufacturers have to file so it is a FACT!
You will see that OPC is completely safe to use. No major health hazards, non flamable, no respiratory protection required, NOT HAZARDOUS TO TRANSPORT ACCORDING TO D.O.T. REGULATIONS, exempted from listing on the TSCA inventory of chemical substances, does not fall under Section 302, 304, 312 or 313 for toxic or hazardous chemicals AND under California State Law, I quote, "
THIS PRODUCT CONTAINS NO CHEMICALS LISTED BY THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA UNDER THE SAFE DRINKING WATER AND TOXIC ENFORCEMENT ACT OF 1986 AS BEING KNOWN TO CAUSE CANCER, BIRTH DEFECTS, OR OTHER REPRODUCTIVE HARM."
How much safer can a product be and yet still has such cleaning power?
What about the Meg's SD?
It is classified as a CORROSIVE LIQUID containing potassium hydroxide, it is a combustible liquid, has an S5 Poison schedule, is TOXIC TO AQUATIC ORGANISMS, several of the ingredients have listed toxicity levels. There is an entire section on ECOLOGICAL INFORMATION on Page 10 of the MSDS stating clearly DO NOT allow product to contaminate water and to dispose of the product properly as it is HIGHLY TOXIC to fish and other aquatic organisms. It is also classified as a Class 8 Corrosive material and has a Hazchem rating of: 2x and a Class 8 rating for dangerous goods for land, sea and air transport as well.
How about Meg's All Purpose Cleaner you ask?
MSDS here:
http://www.meguiars.com.au/msds_files/D10105.pdf
Chemwatch Hazard Rating:
Body Contact: HIGH
Toxicity: Moderate
Chronic: Moderate
S5 Poison Schedule, combustible, is listed under the Australia Exposure Standards, components have a listed toxicity level,
GROUP 3 CARCINOGEN!!!, listed as a COMBUSTIBLE LIQUID for transport labels.
So..... back to the point at hand. Are all the products the same if they all perform the same function? Need I say more?
IS OPC SAFE FOR PAINT COMPARED WITH DEGREASERS FROM OTHER MANUFACTURERS?
Maybe you should take a close look at the MSDS sheets for all the products and decide which ones you want to use and which ones you might want to take some other precautionary measures with.
The entire list of Optimum's MSDS sheets are here:
http://www.optimumcarcare.com.au/content/38/msds.html
Meg's is here:
MSDS | Meguiar's
As I said, many products on the market and we are all free to choose any that we like.
Look up the FACTS and make up your own minds. All this disagreements, accusations, etc. are all uncalled for.
If you don't like it, don't use it.
---------- Post added at 04:08 PM ---------- 6 hour anti-bump limit - Previous post was at 04:03 PM ----------
There is no such thing as degreaser and apc is not safe. Showtime i was once like youm OPC is everything. but now i see the true picture. Hope you enjoy the process of finding out the truth
Maybe we should find out the truth first before preaching it to others....
Link for your convenience.
OPC
http://www.optimumcarcare.com.au/msds/MSDS%20Power%20Clean%20PC2008%202009%281%29.pdf
SD
http://www.meguiars.com.au/msds_files/D10805.pdf
APC
http://www.meguiars.com.au/msds_files/D10105.pdf
Dissapointing.....