Menu
Home
Post Something
Forums
Current Activity
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
News & Features
The Marketplace
Cars for Sale
Engine and Performance
Chassis and Wheels
Exterior and Body
Interior and Cockpit
ICE - In Car Entertainment
Car Shops and Services
Toys and Wares
All Other Stuff
Jobs and Vacancies
Looking For
Members
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Current Activity
New posts
Search forums
Menu
Log in
Register
Reply to thread
See what others are reading now! Try Forums >
Current Activity
Home
Forums
Car Brands
Car Manufacturers
Proton
NEW SATRIA R3 Topic
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Message
<blockquote data-quote="riggy" data-source="post: 207371" data-attributes="member: 5465"><p>Hi again,</p><p></p><p>One problem (or good thing) about being a manufacturer is that manufacturers can make bulk purchases, hence get large discounts. However, I am actually wondering what the case is with proton (as a whole..not the r3 project only). Take for example the SR4 seats. Do you know the only real difference is the way the stiching/pattern is sewn compared to the sr3? The width is almost the same ( so they'd be as 'comfortable' as the sr3s). You're actually paying so much for a more rounded headrest, and some fancy stiching. So the question about why proton specified the sr4 is quite a mystery. Motorsports div should have made it more of a pure race car than what it is. </p><p></p><p>Say for example the management of proton had gone to the motorsport div and said "oh great motorsport head of proton, here is the budget for you to make a race spec satria for us to sell to the public at large." </p><p></p><p>"Sure, whats the budget?" asks the great head of proton motorsports.</p><p></p><p>"You have a ceiling of RM17,000 premium over the standard GTI" answers management.</p><p></p><p>So they had RM17,000 (NOTE that in the sales price it says R3 package is around that figure). And what did they do? buy RM6,000.00 seats. looks like thats about close to 40% of the budget. Now, the question is, is 40% of the R3 budget sound reasonable when you could use the 40% on something that adds power, braking or handling? Conclusion to point 1, its not becoz of the manufacturer having a big headache. </p><p></p><p>They put themselves into such a situation. I mean...aside from aluminium parts, why not spec a pair of racing cams with the money? cams cost at the most RM3000 a pair, why not send the head for gasflowed porting and polishing? i think labour on it would cost less than that. Why not send the bottom end for dynamic balancing? a lighter flywheel? lightweight crankshaft pulley? Instead of spending 40% of the budget on seats!???? seats should be around 20% of the equation.</p><p></p><p>A conspricacy theory: someone made money specifying those seats. The directors of RECARO malaysia can report to their head honcos in Germany "herr big boss of good seats, guess what? We managed to CON-vince proton to use sr4 seats for their 150units limited edition car!" "wunderbar!" answers germany. There you have it. Its the VENDORS OF PROTON controlling the manufacturer...It should be the other way round. </p><p>*note this is totally fiction, unless its true of course!*</p><p></p><p></p><p>Now it is all this that makes me question the actual purpose of this exercise called the r3. I still think the purest, and best Proton from the wira, putra, satria stable was the Wira 1.8 made in 1996-1997. It had a chassis with extra welding spots like the LANCER GSR/evo 1 (WITHOUT the chicken pox look like on the R3 strut towers - why didn't they spec smoother looking weld spots? If a person with no idea of this they'd say the r3 was an accident car), a nice big wing for stability (it actually works), recaro njoys, momo, a very tunable mitsu 1.8 (note diff ecu, cam settings). And proton didnt have to try hard. its a classic all on its own (it already has cult status), I get 1.8 owners telling me about ppl asking them whether their car is for sale all the time.</p><p></p><p>to quote faisal: "Why SR4?? man you people farny laa. we give premium parts don't want.. we give say too xpensive.. give cheap stuff complain..never can pls anyone" </p><p>Honestly, Proton isn't giving, it is we consumers who have to pay for this premium parts. If it were 'giving', like the spirit of christmas, the r3 wouldnt cost RM77k..it should be 72k. </p><p></p><p>more than 2 malaysian sen worth</p><p></p><p>regards,</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="riggy, post: 207371, member: 5465"] Hi again, One problem (or good thing) about being a manufacturer is that manufacturers can make bulk purchases, hence get large discounts. However, I am actually wondering what the case is with proton (as a whole..not the r3 project only). Take for example the SR4 seats. Do you know the only real difference is the way the stiching/pattern is sewn compared to the sr3? The width is almost the same ( so they'd be as 'comfortable' as the sr3s). You're actually paying so much for a more rounded headrest, and some fancy stiching. So the question about why proton specified the sr4 is quite a mystery. Motorsports div should have made it more of a pure race car than what it is. Say for example the management of proton had gone to the motorsport div and said "oh great motorsport head of proton, here is the budget for you to make a race spec satria for us to sell to the public at large." "Sure, whats the budget?" asks the great head of proton motorsports. "You have a ceiling of RM17,000 premium over the standard GTI" answers management. So they had RM17,000 (NOTE that in the sales price it says R3 package is around that figure). And what did they do? buy RM6,000.00 seats. looks like thats about close to 40% of the budget. Now, the question is, is 40% of the R3 budget sound reasonable when you could use the 40% on something that adds power, braking or handling? Conclusion to point 1, its not becoz of the manufacturer having a big headache. They put themselves into such a situation. I mean...aside from aluminium parts, why not spec a pair of racing cams with the money? cams cost at the most RM3000 a pair, why not send the head for gasflowed porting and polishing? i think labour on it would cost less than that. Why not send the bottom end for dynamic balancing? a lighter flywheel? lightweight crankshaft pulley? Instead of spending 40% of the budget on seats!???? seats should be around 20% of the equation. A conspricacy theory: someone made money specifying those seats. The directors of RECARO malaysia can report to their head honcos in Germany "herr big boss of good seats, guess what? We managed to CON-vince proton to use sr4 seats for their 150units limited edition car!" "wunderbar!" answers germany. There you have it. Its the VENDORS OF PROTON controlling the manufacturer...It should be the other way round. *note this is totally fiction, unless its true of course!* Now it is all this that makes me question the actual purpose of this exercise called the r3. I still think the purest, and best Proton from the wira, putra, satria stable was the Wira 1.8 made in 1996-1997. It had a chassis with extra welding spots like the LANCER GSR/evo 1 (WITHOUT the chicken pox look like on the R3 strut towers - why didn't they spec smoother looking weld spots? If a person with no idea of this they'd say the r3 was an accident car), a nice big wing for stability (it actually works), recaro njoys, momo, a very tunable mitsu 1.8 (note diff ecu, cam settings). And proton didnt have to try hard. its a classic all on its own (it already has cult status), I get 1.8 owners telling me about ppl asking them whether their car is for sale all the time. to quote faisal: "Why SR4?? man you people farny laa. we give premium parts don't want.. we give say too xpensive.. give cheap stuff complain..never can pls anyone" Honestly, Proton isn't giving, it is we consumers who have to pay for this premium parts. If it were 'giving', like the spirit of christmas, the r3 wouldnt cost RM77k..it should be 72k. more than 2 malaysian sen worth regards, [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Post reply
The Marketplace Latest
original rare Rays Volk Racing TE37SL Black Edition...
Started by
david tao
Chassis and Wheels
Honda city JSracing gtwing spoiler
Started by
jeff6126
Exterior and Body
Honda civic fd ~car spray(Ferrari red)
Started by
jeff6126
Exterior and Body
Honda jazz fit gk flrs body kit
Started by
jeff6126
Exterior and Body
BMW F10 ~M5 front skirt lip with glossy black
Started by
jeff6126
Exterior and Body
Kia Forte gtwing spoiler
Started by
jeff6126
Exterior and Body
BMW F30 M3 front skirt lip
Started by
jeff6126
Exterior and Body
Proton Saga VVT Evo Front Bonnet Hood
Started by
jeff6126
Exterior and Body
Perodua bezza gear up body kit/spoiler
Started by
jeff6126
Exterior and Body
BMW F10 ~M5 front bumper set ~M5 kidney grille...
Started by
jeff6126
Exterior and Body
Posts refresh every 5 minutes
WTA Evo 7 question
1)evo7 using ron95 or 97? or both ?
2)full fuel tank drive in city can go up to how many kms? (how many litre / kms) (full tank $?)
3)maintenance if compare mazda rx8 whice is easy?
4)any place intro get evo7 good...
Merry Xmas & Happy 2007!!
Just a little something, to wish all u guys a Merry Christmas & a Happy New 2007.
2006 has been a great year. Met all you great people, learned a lot from u guys, and had great fun and outings. Thanks to all of you...
Greedy Type-R BOV
Anyone here used or using this BOV ?
how does it sound like ?
suitable for low boost and high boost ?
thanks mate.
SDF : u were using it rite ?
Recent Posts
Darker Design : Mercedes-Benz Launches GLA Nightfall Edition in Malaysia
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
Honda Malaysia Doubles Down on Hybrids: New CR-V Launches with Dual e:HEV...
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
BateriHub Reaches 200-Store Milestone, Becomes Malaysia’s Largest...
Started by
The_Mechanic
News and Features
Been stalking for 3 years edy
Started by
dheepadarshan95
Introduction and Newbies
Recommendation: Turbocharger for 4B11 N.A engine
Started by
Mitevo7
Car Modification
Search
Online now
Enjoying Zerotohundred?
Log-in
for an ad-less experience
Home
Forums
Car Brands
Car Manufacturers
Proton
NEW SATRIA R3 Topic