Goodyear F1 Directional 5 vs Michelin Pilot Sport 3

[ddv_nk12]

How much is the D5 and PS3 for 205/45/16 or 205/50/16? Tyres need to be changed soon. Currently on Yoko A-Drive.

 

[vr2turbo]

How much is the D5 and PS3 for 205/45/16 or 205/50/16? Tyres need to be changed soon. Currently on Yoko A-Drive.

From members posting, don't have D5 price....
205/45R16
Achilles ATR - RM200 Tee 3 Auto & Tyre Service Sdn Bhd (May-13)
Michelin PS 3 - RM467 3S Specialists Ara Damansara (Apr-13) B+A+N.Gas
Thunderer - RM215 Extreme Wheels Ampang (July 12)
Yokohama A.Drive R1 - RM280 Tee 3 Auto & Tyre Service Sdn Bhd (May-13)

205/50R16
Achilles ATR Sport - RM220 Soon Jaya Tyres & Batteries Service Centre Malim Jaya Melaka (Oct 12)
Dunlop FM901 - RM260 Tee 3 Auto & Tyre Service Sdn Bhd (May-13)
Federa SS595 - RM265 Tee 3 Auto & Tyre Service Sdn Bhd (June-13)
Hankook S1Evo - RM380 Soon Seng Jaya Tyre Tmn Industri Malim Jaya Melaka (Oct 12)
Michelin PRIMACY LC - RM509 3S Specialists Ara Damansara (Apr-13) B+A+N.Gas
Michelin PS 3 - RM472 3S Specialists Ara Damansara (Apr-13) B+A+N.Gas
Michelin PS3 - RM465 Ban Hooi Klang (Aug 12)
Michelin PS3 - RM508 Pusat Servic Tayar BH, Lebuh Medan Ipoh, Ipoh (June 12)
Nangkang NS-II - RM250 Soon Seng Jaya Tyre Tmn Industri Malim Jaya Melaka (Oct 12)
Neuton NT 5000 - RM220 Soon Jaya Tyres & Batteries Service Centre Malim Jaya Melaka (Oct 12)
Neuton NT 8000 - RM225 Soon Jaya Tyres & Batteries Service Centre Malim Jaya Melaka (Oct 12)
Thunderer - RM225 Extreme Wheels Ampang (july 12)
Toyo T1R - RM350 Heng Wong Tyre & Service Taman Merdeka Permai Melaka (Oct 12)
Toyo T1R - RM410 Quicksave (May 12)
Yokohama A-Drive R1 - RM290 Sunway Tek Meng (Jun'12)
Yokohama A-Drive R1 - RM305 Kien Hoe (Yokohama) USJ19 (July 13)
Yokohama S-Drive - RM370 Ban Hooi Klang (Aug 12)

 

[beatnik]

I have used both PS3 & F1 D5 on 195/55/15..

All I can say.. because price wise is not much different between both for this size.. PS3 >>> F1 D5

I'm a bit disappointed with F1 D5 as I had high hopes..
aquaplaning is no where near PS3
braking also not as good
noise? about the same
F1 D5 feels more comfy
handling? D5 sometimes a bit squirmy.. i don't know but i prefer PS3.

Maybe for bigger size when price is taken into consideration, maybe F1 D5 seems like a good buy, but when both prices are close it's a no brainer actually.. PS3 wins hands down. (i know a lot of ppl hate PS3 coz of its price, but its a good tire really).

i would rate F1 D5 just above average.

 

[ixeo]

I installed F1 D5, so far so good. Reason I did not wish to go back to PS3 is due to the rubber flaking off, although it did not affect performance, though I kept imagining a tyre explosion.

Yeah, price wise, PS3 and F1 D5, especially at 15" size is negligible.

 

[FGT]

I installed F1 D5, so far so good. Reason I did not wish to go back to PS3 is due to the rubber flaking off, although it did not affect performance, though I kept imagining a tyre explosion.

Yeah, price wise, PS3 and F1 D5, especially at 15" size is negligible.

I'm going for F1 D5 as well. One question though -- on GY website, the size for 15" is 195/50/15 but ZTH price list have 195/55/15 on it. Both sizes available?

 

[ixeo]

I'm going for F1 D5 as well. One question though -- on GY website, the size for 15" is 195/50/15 but ZTH price list have 195/55/15 on it. Both sizes available?

Yes both size available. I paid RM245 for 195/50 R15.

 

[vr2turbo]

Yes both size available. I paid RM245 for 195/50 R15.

Yup, PS3 for this size around that price too....

 

[FGT]

Yup, PS3 for this size around that price too....

I was quoted RM235 for D5 and RM265 for PS3 for the 195/50/15 size. That's from a GY dealer. Weird thing is PS3 got ready stock, D5 have to put deposit and come back next day. :P

 

[vr2turbo]

I was quoted RM235 for D5 and RM265 for PS3 for the 195/50/15 size. That's from a GY dealer. Weird thing is PS3 got ready stock, D5 have to put deposit and come back next day. :P

For RM265 can get 195/55R15 already. 50 series is cheaper.
Probably they stock PS3 because selling better.

 

[FGT]

For RM265 can get 195/55R15 already. 50 series is cheaper.
Probably they stock PS3 because selling better.

That's what i thought also. Any shops to recommend for those D5s in PJ? Somehow I still prefer GY but would go for 55 ones. :P

 

[vr2turbo]

That's what i thought also. Any shops to recommend for those D5s in PJ? Somehow I still prefer GY but would go for 55 ones. :P

Can Try HupShun in Sunway. The other shops I know also don't stock the D5....

 

[stupidcar]

That's what i thought also. Any shops to recommend for those D5s in PJ? Somehow I still prefer GY but would go for 55 ones. :P

FGT= Fagg*t?!?!

 

[FGT]

Can Try HupShun in Sunway. The other shops I know also don't stock the D5....

Will do. Thanks man. I don't mind having to wait one day for them to order the stock as long as I get the tyres I want at a reasonable price. :)

FGT= Fagg*t?!?!

That's very immature bro.

 

[stupidcar]

Will do. Thanks man. I don't mind having to wait one day for them to order the stock as long as I get the tyres I want at a reasonable price. :)



That's very immature bro.

Joking lah. Have been reading alot of Spooderman comics lately. AHAHAH. No harm towards your name.

 

[vr2turbo]

Will do. Thanks man. I don't mind having to wait one day for them to order the stock as long as I get the tyres I want at a reasonable price. :)

Bro., where from?

Try calling them..
HupShun Tyres Auto Car Care Sdn. Bhd.
11, Jln. PJS11/7, Bandar Sunway
46150 Petaling Jaya
Tel: 03-5632 9926 , 5637 2275
Tee: 019-332 1106

Heard this place is cheap..
Weng Heng Tayar
15 Jalan G/25G Bukit Kemuning Batu 8 40400 Shah Alam
(opposite 99 Speedmarket and next to KheBeng Chinese School)
GPS location/Google Map : 3.0168841N 101.5293065E
Contact: 016-6555122 Han