Not apple-to-apple comparison I think. Evo 9 is much more expensive right? Also they're different types of cars: turbo vs NA, AWD vs FF, sedan vs coupe.
Anyway, I personally much prefer the Evo cuz it's a much faster car (in straight and corners, dry or wet), & more practical due to 4 doors, and looks better as well IMHO. The only downside would be fuel consumption and higher maintenance due to turbo charged engine. (CMIIW).